Welding 9% nickel steel is the most demanding task in LNG tank construction, because the plate gets its cryogenic toughness from a delicate tempered microstructure and the weld metal must stay tough at -196°C.
Welding 9% nickel steel for LNG and cryogenic service uses nickel-base filler metals, because austenitic weld metal stays tough at -196°C. Keep heat input low and interpass temperature below 150 to 250°C, demagnetise the plate to prevent arc blow, avoid carbon steel contamination, and qualify the procedure with Charpy impact tests at -196°C.
This guide covers the material, consumables, processes, magnetism control, heat input, qualification and defects. Nickel is what gives the steel its low-temperature toughness; our guide to the effect of alloying elements on the properties of steel explains the metallurgy behind it.
The procedure must also prove its toughness by test, which is covered in our Charpy impact test guide. Requirements always depend on the code, specification and contract for the tank or vessel being built.

- 9% nickel steel (ASTM A353 and A553 Type I) is the standard inner-wall plate for LNG storage tanks, tough down to -196°C.
- Nickel-base fillers are used because austenitic weld metal has no brittle transition, and no post-weld heat treatment is needed.
- Residual magnetism causes arc blow, so measure the field and demagnetise before welding; avoid magnets on the plate.
- Keep heat input low and interpass temperature controlled; TWI suggests a maximum of 250°C, ideally below 150°C.
- Never use carbon steel filler or tack welds, and keep the joint clean and dry to avoid porosity and cracking.
- Qualify the procedure with Charpy tests at -196°C and monitor production against the qualified limits.
What Is 9% Nickel Steel and Why Is It Used for LNG?
9% nickel steel is a low-carbon ferritic steel alloyed with about 9% nickel that stays tough at temperatures down to -196°C.
Liquefied natural gas is stored at about -162°C. At that temperature, carbon steel fails by brittle fracture, while 9% nickel steel keeps its toughness. It has been the standard material for the inner wall of LNG storage tanks since the 1950s, and it is also used for other cryogens such as liquid oxygen and argon. The plate is covered by ASTM A353 and ASTM A553 Type I, and by EN 10028-4 in Europe.
| Grade | Heat treatment | Min. yield strength | Tensile strength |
|---|---|---|---|
| ASTM A353 | Double normalised and tempered | 515 MPa (75 ksi) | 690 to 825 MPa |
| ASTM A553 Type I | Quenched and tempered | 585 MPa (85 ksi) | 690 to 825 MPa |
| EN 10028-4 X7Ni9 and X8Ni9 | Quenched and tempered (European grades) | See the EN 10028-4 table for thickness | See the EN 10028-4 table |
Carbon content is about 0.13% maximum and nickel is about 8.5 to 9.5%, which gives good weldability and a ductile-to-brittle transition that is below the service temperature. For the wider metallurgy of weld zones, see our welding metallurgy guide for inspectors.
Why Is 9% Nickel Steel Sensitive to Welding Heat?
9% nickel steel is sensitive to welding heat because its toughness depends on a heat-treated structure of tempered martensite with a small amount of stable austenite, which welding thermal cycles can alter. The heat-affected zone can therefore lose toughness if heat input and interpass temperature are not controlled.
Research on the plate describes about 5 to 10% by volume of austenite that stays stable at cryogenic temperature. Reheating during welding changes this structure close to the weld, and coarse grain growth in the HAZ reduces toughness, as covered in our guide to grain growth in the HAZ.
The plate is not post-weld heat treated after nickel-base welding. This is why the thermal controls during welding, not a later heat treatment, protect the toughness of the joint. Where a code does set PWHT by thickness, the PWHT soak time calculator helps with the soak time, but check that the code applies to your equipment.
Which Welding Consumables Are Used for 9% Nickel Steel?
Nickel-base consumables are used for 9% nickel steel because the austenitic weld metal has no ductile-to-brittle transition and stays tough at -196°C without post-weld heat treatment. They are typically Ni-Cr-Mo or Ni-Cr-Fe types selected by the project procedure.
Typical examples are ENiCrMo-6 and ENiCrFe-2 type covered electrodes and ERNiCrMo-3 type wires, but the supplier data and the qualified procedure decide the exact choice. Consumable specifications include AWS A5.11 for covered electrodes and AWS A5.14 for bare wires. Our guide to nickel alloy consumables under ASME SFA-5.11 explains the electrode classes in detail.
- Strength: nickel-base weld metal usually has lower yield strength than the plate, so the tank design must allow for this undermatching.
- Cleanliness: nickel weld metal is sensitive to sulphur, lead and other contaminants, which can cause porosity and hot cracking.
- Storage: electrodes and fluxes must be kept dry; see welding consumable storage and handling best practices.
- Cost: nickel consumables are expensive, so deposit estimates and waste control matter.
Which Welding Processes Are Used for 9% Nickel Steel?
SMAW, SAW, GTAW and GMAW or flux-cored welding with nickel-base consumables are all used for 9% nickel steel, with the choice set by position, thickness, productivity and the qualified procedure. Large tanks commonly combine them: SAW for long seams and SMAW or GTAW for out-of-position joints and roots.
| Process | Typical use | Strengths | Limits |
|---|---|---|---|
| SMAW | Site joints, out-of-position welds, repairs | Flexible, easy to use in the field | Lower productivity, moisture-sensitive electrodes, slag removal |
| SAW | Long horizontal shell seams | High productivity, consistent, controlled heat input | Flat or horizontal only, flux handling and dryness |
| GTAW | Root passes, thin sections, repairs | Clean, precise, high weld quality | Slow, skill-intensive |
| GMAW and FCAW | Productivity welding with nickel wires | Higher deposition rates | Fusion and spatter control, gas and parameter sensitivity |
For process fundamentals see our guides to SMAW, GTAW and GMAW.
How Do You Prevent Arc Blow on 9% Nickel Steel?
Prevent arc blow by measuring the residual magnetism, demagnetising the plate when it exceeds the specified limit, and keeping magnets and strong electrical currents away from the joint. 9% nickel steel can become strongly magnetised, and TWI notes that this can make arc welding impossible.
Arc blow is the deflection of the arc by a magnetic field, and it causes poor fusion, spatter and unstable beads. Common sources of magnetism in a fabrication yard are lifting magnets, magnetic clamps, magnetic particle test yokes, and the welding current itself when the work lead is placed badly.
- Measure the field with a gauss meter. Specifications commonly set a limit of a few millitesla (tens of gauss); use the value in your project specification.
- Demagnetise with a demagnetising coil or yoke following the supplier’s procedure.
- Use mechanical clamps and non-magnetic fixtures instead of magnetic ones, and avoid lifting magnets on the plate.
- Place the work lead symmetrically and use short arcs and stringer technique; avoid long, high-current runs near the plate edge.
- Prefer penetrant testing; if magnetic particle testing is used on the plate, demagnetise afterwards.
How Do You Control Heat Input and Interpass Temperature?
Control heat input by setting current, voltage and travel speed in the procedure, and control interpass temperature by measuring it before each pass and pausing welding when it exceeds the limit. Heat input rises quickly when travel speed falls, so speed must be monitored in production.
TWI recommends limiting the interpass temperature to a maximum of 250°C and ideally below 150°C for 9% nickel steel. The qualified WPS sets the actual limits, and heat input and maximum interpass temperature are supplementary essential variables when impact testing applies, as explained in the PQR guide. Measure interpass temperature with a contact pyrometer or temperature-indicating crayons placed beside the joint.
How Should Joints Be Prepared and Plate Handled?
Prepare joints with wider grooves than for carbon steel, keep everything clean and dry, and handle the plate without magnets or damage. Careful preparation and handling prevent the most common defects of nickel weld metal.
- Groove geometry: nickel weld metal is sluggish and wets poorly, so use wider included angles or U-grooves to give access and reduce lack of fusion at the sidewalls.
- Cutting and grinding: grind thermally cut edges back to clean metal, and use tools reserved for nickel and 9% nickel steel to avoid iron contamination.
- Cleaning: remove oil, paint, oxide and moisture before welding, and clean between passes.
- Tacks and attachments: use nickel-base filler for tack welds and temporary attachments, and remove attachments by grinding, not gouging, followed by penetrant testing.
- Arc strikes: never strike an arc on the plate outside the joint; grind and test any arc strike.
- Handling: use non-magnetic slings and clamps, and re-measure the magnetic field after handling.
How Do You Weld a 9% Nickel Steel Joint Step by Step?
Weld a 9% nickel steel joint by verifying the documents, controlling magnetism, preparing and cleaning the groove, setting up consumables, welding within the thermal limits, and inspecting and recording the result. The numbered steps below follow common industry practice and must be adapted to the qualified WPS.
- Verify materials and procedure documents. Check plate heat numbers, mill certificates, impact test reports and the approved WPS and PQR. Confirm that the filler metal batch and heat treatment records match the procedure.
- Check and control residual magnetism. Measure the magnetic field at the joint with a gauss meter and demagnetise any plate or assembly above the specification limit. Keep lifting magnets and magnetic particle yokes away from the plate.
- Prepare and clean the joint. Cut and grind the groove to the specified angle, remove oxide, paint, oil and cutting residue, and keep the surface dry. Use grinding wheels and brushes reserved for nickel alloys and 9% nickel steel.
- Prepare consumables and set the conditions. Dry and store nickel electrodes and fluxes as the supplier requires, shelter the work from wind and moisture, and confirm that ambient and plate temperatures meet the procedure. See the guide to welding consumable storage and handling.
- Fit up and tack with the correct filler. Assemble and tack with nickel-base filler metal as the qualified procedure requires, never carbon steel filler, and avoid arc strikes outside the joint.
- Weld within the heat input and interpass limits. Deposit stringer or narrow weave beads with low heat input, measure interpass temperature before each pass and pause when it exceeds the limit. Watch for arc blow and for lack of fusion at the groove sidewalls.
- Inspect during and after welding. Inspect each layer visually, clean between passes, and carry out penetrant testing, radiography or ultrasonic testing as required. Method choice is explained in the NDT method selection guide.
- Record, test and release the joint. Record heat input, interpass temperature and consumable batches, test production samples if required, and complete the documentation before the joint is released for hydrostatic testing.

Weld with stringer or narrow weave beads, which control heat input and help fusion. Remove slag and examine each layer before the next, because defects buried in a nickel weld are difficult and costly to repair.
How Do You Qualify the Procedure and Test the Weld?
Qualify the procedure by welding and testing a coupon under the intended conditions, including Charpy impact tests at -196°C on the weld metal and heat-affected zone. Production welds must then stay within the qualified limits, particularly heat input and interpass temperature.
| Test | Purpose | Typical condition |
|---|---|---|
| Charpy V-notch | Toughness of weld metal and HAZ | -196°C, weld metal and fusion line locations |
| Transverse tensile | Joint strength | Room temperature, minimum as specified |
| Bend tests | Ductility and soundness | Side or face and root bends |
| Macro examination | Fusion, profile, defects | Cross-section etched |
| NDT of weld | Detect flaws | RT or UT, plus PT; MT is not effective on non-magnetic nickel weld metal |
9% nickel steel plate is P-No. 11A Group 1 in ASME Section IX. The code requires re-qualification when supplementary essential variables change and impact testing applies. For the practical steps, see our guides to preparing a WPS and PQR and the NDT method selection guide. Acceptance values for impact tests are usually set as absorbed energy or lateral expansion in the applicable tank code, such as API 620 Appendix Q or EN 14620, and the contract specification.
How Much Nickel Filler Metal Does a Joint Need?
Estimate weld metal from the groove cross-section area, convert it to weight with the density of nickel alloy, and allow for deposition efficiency. Nickel consumables are expensive, so a quick estimate helps to plan quantities.
Density of nickel-base weld metal is about 8.4 g/cm3, higher than the 7.85 g/cm3 of carbon steel. The 60% recovery is an assumption; use the supplier’s figure.
What Problems Occur When Welding 9% Nickel Steel?
The most common problems are arc blow, lack of fusion, porosity, hot cracking and loss of toughness from excess heat. Most are caused by preparation, contamination and thermal control, not by the plate itself.
| Problem | Typical cause | Prevention |
|---|---|---|
| Arc blow | Residual magnetism, magnets, bad work lead position | Measure field, demagnetise, non-magnetic clamps |
| Lack of fusion | Sluggish nickel weld pool, narrow groove, low heat | Wider groove, correct weave, check sidewalls |
| Porosity | Moisture, contamination, damp electrodes or flux | Dry consumables, clean joint, shelter from wind |
| Hot cracking and microfissures | Sulphur, lead or other contaminants, high restraint or heat | Cleanliness, correct consumable, low heat input |
| Low toughness in HAZ or weld | Excess heat input or high interpass temperature | Limit heat input and interpass, monitor in production |
| Arc strike damage | Arc started on the plate outside the joint | Strike in the groove, grind and PT any strike |
General weld defect names and acceptance concepts are described in our guide to welding defects types, causes and remedies. For repair welding on 9% nickel tanks after damage, see the post-blast weld integrity assessment of LNG facilities, which discusses impact testing of repair welds.
What Health and Safety Controls Apply?
Welding nickel-base consumables produces fume containing nickel compounds, which are classified as carcinogenic to humans, so effective fume control and respiratory protection are required. Follow the safety data sheet and your exposure assessment.
- Use local exhaust ventilation and keep the welder out of the plume; see welding ventilation requirements indoor and outdoor.
- Use respiratory protection where the exposure assessment requires it, especially inside tanks and other enclosed spaces.
- Control grinding dust from nickel alloys and 9% nickel steel.
- When cryogenic Charpy tests are done in a laboratory, liquid nitrogen creates cold-burn and asphyxiation hazards, so use proper handling and ventilation.
What Practical Notes Apply in India and the Gulf?
Humidity, sea air, heat and client specifications shape 9% nickel steel welding in India and the Gulf, where LNG terminals and tank projects are built. These notes are general practice; project specifications govern.
- Moisture: monsoon humidity and coastal air raise the risk of porosity, so shelter the work, dry the joint and control electrode storage.
- Heat: high ambient temperature can make interpass control harder, since the plate starts warm. Measure the plate and watch the limit.
- Contamination: salt, dust and sand contaminate nickel weld metal, so enclose welding areas and clean often.
- Client specifications: LNG owners and EPC contractors commonly require qualified welders, procedure qualification at -196°C and third-party inspection. Follow the contract.
What Are the Most Common Mistakes When Welding 9% Nickel Steel?
The most common mistakes are ignoring magnetism, exceeding heat input and interpass limits, using the wrong filler or tack welds, and welding on a contaminated or damp joint. Each can lead to defects or to toughness loss that is found only at test.
- Not measuring magnetism. Arc blow often follows lifting magnets or magnetic yokes.
- Letting interpass temperature drift. Production welding must stay within the qualified limit.
- Carbon steel tacks or attachments. They create brittle zones in the weld.
- Weak fusion on narrow grooves. Nickel weld metal does not flow like carbon steel.
- Uncontrolled arc strikes. Strikes outside the joint can harden and crack the plate surface.
- Damp or poorly stored consumables. Moisture causes porosity.
- Unqualified changes. A new filler batch, process or heat input range may need re-qualification.
Requirements depend on the code edition, specification and contract applicable to your project.
Quick Reference: Welding 9% Nickel Steel Cheat Sheet
Use this table as a quick check before welding. Confirm every value against the WPS, code and project specification. Our pre-weld and post-weld inspection checklist helps with the general checks.
| Topic | Rule of thumb |
|---|---|
| Filler metal | Nickel-base, per the qualified procedure; never carbon steel |
| PWHT | Generally none for nickel-filler LNG tank welds |
| Interpass temperature | TWI: maximum 250°C, ideally below 150°C; the WPS controls |
| Heat input | Low, monitored, within the qualified range |
| Magnetism | Measure with a gauss meter; demagnetise above the limit |
| Groove | Wider than for carbon steel, to avoid sidewall lack of fusion |
| Impact test | Charpy at -196°C on weld metal and HAZ |
| NDT | RT or UT plus PT; MT is not effective on nickel weld metal |
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is 9% nickel steel used for LNG tanks?
Liquefied natural gas is stored at about -162 degrees C, and ordinary carbon steel becomes brittle at that temperature. The nickel content of 9% nickel steel keeps the plate tough down to -196 degrees C, which gives a safety margin over the storage temperature. The steel also has good strength and weldability, which is why it has been the standard inner-wall material for LNG tanks for decades.
Can 9% nickel steel be welded with carbon steel or matching filler?
Carbon steel filler is not suitable, because the weld metal would be brittle at cryogenic temperature. Matching 9% nickel filler needs a quench and temper heat treatment after welding to reach full toughness, which is impractical for large tanks. Nickel-base fillers give austenitic weld metal that stays tough without post-weld heat treatment, so they are the normal choice for site welding.
Does 9% nickel steel need preheat or post-weld heat treatment?
With nickel-base filler, preheat is normally not required because the plate has low carbon content, although the joint must be dry and above the minimum temperature in the procedure. Post-weld heat treatment is generally not applied to LNG tank welds, and it can damage the plate’s tempered structure. Some codes for piping or pressure vessels set PWHT rules by thickness, so check the code applicable to the equipment.
What is arc blow and why does it affect 9% nickel steel?
Arc blow is the deflection of the welding arc by a magnetic field, which causes poor fusion, spatter and unstable bead shape. Nine per cent nickel steel can pick up and hold strong residual magnetism from lifting magnets, magnetic clamps, magnetic particle yokes and welding current. The remedy is to measure the field with a gauss meter and demagnetise the plate before welding.
What interpass temperature is used for 9% nickel steel?
TWI recommends limiting the interpass temperature to a maximum of 250 degrees C and ideally below 150 degrees C for 9% nickel steel. Project procedures often set a stricter maximum, and the value in the qualified WPS controls. Interpass temperature is a supplementary essential variable when impact testing is required, so production must not exceed the qualified limit.
At what temperature are 9% nickel steel welds Charpy tested?
Impact tests for LNG tank plate and welds are normally carried out at -196 degrees C using a liquid nitrogen bath. Test locations include the weld metal and the heat-affected zone at the fusion line and set distances from it. Acceptance is usually expressed as absorbed energy or lateral expansion, using the values in the applicable code and project specification.
Can 9% nickel steel be welded with GTAW or GMAW instead of SMAW?
Yes. SMAW, SAW, GTAW and GMAW or flux-cored processes with nickel-base consumables have all been used for LNG tank construction, with the choice depending on position, thickness, productivity and the qualified procedure. GTAW is common for roots and repairs, SAW for long seams, and SMAW for out-of-position site joints. Whatever the process, heat input and interpass limits apply.
Key Terms
- 9% nickel steel
- A low-carbon ferritic steel with about 9% nickel that stays tough at cryogenic temperatures, used for LNG storage.
- Arc blow
- The deflection of the welding arc by a magnetic field, causing poor fusion and unstable beads.
- Austenitic weld metal
- Weld metal with a face-centred cubic structure that has no ductile-to-brittle transition.
- Interpass temperature
- The temperature of the weld area immediately before the next pass is started.
- Heat input
- The arc energy delivered per unit length of weld, in kilojoules per millimetre.
- Charpy V-notch test
- An impact test that measures the energy a notched specimen absorbs when it fractures.
- Lateral expansion
- The increase in width of a Charpy specimen at the notch after fracture, used as a ductility measure.
- Demagnetisation
- Reducing the residual magnetic field in steel to prevent arc blow.
Conclusion
Welding 9% nickel steel succeeds when the procedure protects the plate’s toughness: nickel-base filler, controlled heat input and interpass temperature, no residual magnetism, clean and dry joints, and Charpy qualification at -196°C. Production control matters as much as the qualified procedure, because the toughness is only guaranteed within the tested limits.
Plan consumable storage, magnetism checks and temperature monitoring before the first pass, brief the welders on the limits, and keep complete records of every pass. As a next step, use our welding inspection checklist to plan the inspection hold points, and review the temperature and magnetism records after every shift.
Standards and References
- ASTM A353 – Standard Specification for Pressure Vessel Plates, Alloy Steel, Double-Normalized and Tempered 9% Nickel (ASTM International)
- ASTM A553 – Standard Specification for Pressure Vessel Plates, Alloy Steel, Quenched and Tempered 8% and 9% Nickel (ASTM International)
- EN 10028-4 – Flat products made of steels for pressure purposes – Part 4: Nickel alloy steels with specified low temperature properties (CEN)
- EN 14620 – Design and manufacture of site built, vertical, cylindrical, flat-bottomed steel tanks for the storage of refrigerated, liquefied gases (CEN)
- API 620 Appendix Q – Low-pressure storage tanks for liquefied natural gas and other refrigerated liquids (American Petroleum Institute)
- API 625 – Tank Systems for Refrigerated Liquefied Gas Storage (American Petroleum Institute)
- ASME BPVC Section IX – Welding, Brazing, and Fusing Qualifications (ASME)
- ASME BPVC Section VIII Division 1, UG-84 – Charpy impact tests (ASME)
- AWS A5.11 – Specification for Nickel and Nickel-Alloy Covered Welding Electrodes (American Welding Society (AWS))
- AWS A5.14 – Specification for Nickel and Nickel-Alloy Bare Welding Electrodes and Rods (American Welding Society (AWS))
- TWI Job Knowledge 100 – Welding of ferritic cryogenic steels (TWI)
Primary sources: TWI, ASTM International, American Petroleum Institute (API) and American Welding Society (AWS).
This guide was prepared by the WeldFabWorld technical team from the standards listed above. Verify all requirements against the code edition, specification and contract applicable to your project.